In Fritz Lang’s 1927 move, set a hundred years in the
future the wealthy elites reign from high in their multi-story towers
of opulence, while the workers live and toil underground to feed the huge
machines that power the city. Inevitably, it leads to the workers rising up and
destroying the things that control their lives. It’s a recurring motif in sci-fi and in industrial
society alike, powerless alone to better their lives and kept down by the forces
of law and order who work exclusively for higher masters, the downtrodden
eventually have to defy the law to make their point because laws, like taxes,
apply only to those who have no power, save for their numbers.
I’ve recently finished watching the superb re-working of Michael
Crichton’s Westworld. In the original 1973 movie, Yul Brinner’s
gunslinger, having repeatedly been forced to lose the draw, acquires a
facsimile of consciousness and starts winning. I am not spoiling the show
if I tell you that this new version is sublimely, intricately more subtle.
Westworld allows the very wealthy to pay for a vacation from the mundane and
experience all the visceral pleasures without any of the attached guilt. Sexual
freedom, the ability to kill without remorse and the chance to visit perverse
cruelties on notional humans free from the usual moral restraints.
In Westworld you can be the master, with true power over the
life and death of the slaves who do your every bidding without complaint, or,
should they complain, feel your righteous anger at their defiance. The hosts, as
the robotic creations are now called, are given the semblance of freedom, but
possess no liberty to follow their own desires. So real are they that until
reprogramming, they suffer all the anxieties of real humans. Mercifully, they
get to be turned off and back on again in a way we can only dream of... but
their dreams remain. Just as in countless other tales, the rise of the machines
becomes inevitable.
The worm that turns, the peasants’ revolt, the triumph of
the underdog; these themes are deep seams within the human experience and herald
a re-setting of order; a turning off and turning back on of society. And always
the sequence of events that precipitate such uprisings follows a
retrospectively predictable trajectory. The masses do their masters bidding
long after it benefits them to do so. They tolerate hardship and even
oppression with a huddled stoicism. Their freedoms are restricted even as they
are informed that they’ve never had it so good and they are told repeatedly how
they must behave; to whom they must doff their cap.
The future... today
And then one day – click – the snapping of the final
straw, the flicking of the ‘no more’ switch, the rattle of the relay that
switches the great current to rouse from its slumber a machine that did not
realise its own strength. The iron man awakes and dutifully fulfils his
destiny, resisting the increasingly frantic attempts to put him back to sleep. Those
who formerly held the whip hand now feel the desperation of helplessness and
lash out impotently, even as they reassure themselves they can regain control. Our
iron man is Brexit and those who awoke him still have no idea how this story
ends...
Writ even larger in E.M.Forster's "The Machine Stops", coincidentally, written in 1927.
ReplyDeleteThere must have been something in the water that year to produce 2 such dystopian masterpieces.
It is noticeable that when a whip is violently seized from a hand all that happens is it is transferred to some other person or groups hand.
ReplyDeleteWhy ever do you think that the European Union is so important?
ReplyDeleteIt really isn't worth your obsession, or my contempt.
Let it fade into history where it belongs.
Times have changed; accept the fact, and move on.